Diamond Pantheon

Athena, you could search again, being on the end.

Alright, I will search again.

I've found another pentacle symbol.

I've searched again (so Yerkan can do the double search now) and found a brown gem.

Which is an eye color, so I duplicate it and put it in Bluejacket?'s eyes.

Hmm. If that doesn't work, I'll duplicate a blue gem and place them in the eyes.

I will also search twice.

I have a third orange gem and also a potentially very useful Animus Symbol. Perhaps this is the "symbol of [the Kraken's] own power.

A rotsoil for me.

Have we tried every symbol?

-Animus - I've also got one, so I'll duplicate it and try that.
-Karma - worked
-Rotsoil - nope
-Pentacle - nope
-Animus symbol - unlikely to be found

Of course, it may not be a symbol at all.

Shutters come in pairs, right? One goes on either side of the window. This may be the answer to the riddle's 2 sets of 2. So I'll try that too.

-Tries Animus
-Tries shutters, one loot item in each pan

The shutters fit in the pans fairly well, but do not cause anything to happen. Nor does the Animus symbol.

Hmm, both the harp and shutters seem to fit in the pan well, but not when the same objects are in the pans. What if we put one of each in the pans? I'll start by putting my harp into the gold pan and then I will let someone put a shutters into the other pan if they would like. If that doesn't do anything I will switch which pans the objects are in, just to see if that makes a difference.

I also will search now.

I have found a blood phial.